Welcome to Cake It Or Leave It!
At Cake It or Leave It LLC, we specialize in handcrafted, original desserts that satisfy every sweet craving. From our signature oversized stuffed cookies and fudgy brookies to moist banana breads and customizable sugar cookies, there’s something for every palate.
Our menu also features mini cookie cakes perfect for celebrations, chocolate-dipped rose pops, fluffy muffins, and a growing gluten-free line — all made with the finest ingredients and a whole lot of love.
Every treat is crafted to turn ordinary moments into unforgettable indulgences. Whether you’re marking a special occasion or simply treating yourself, Cake It or Leave It brings the magic of homemade goodness straight to your door.
Ready to indulge? Click below to explore our menu and place your order today.
Stuffed Cookies
where classic cookie perfection meets an irresistible surprise inside! These thick, indulgent cookies are baked to golden perfection, each one hiding a rich, gooey center that takes every bite to the next level.
Banana Bread
Each moist and flavorful loaf is made with ripe bananas, rich brown butter, and a touch of sweetness, creating a soft, tender bite every time.
Stuffed Cookies
Banana Breads
Cinnamon Stacks
Muffins
Cookie Cake Cups
Minin Cakes
What Our Customers Are Saying
At Cake It Or Leave It, we believe that our customers are the heart and soul of our business. Your feedback is invaluable to us as it helps us grow, improve, and continue delivering the delectable desserts you love. We are deeply grateful for your support and take pride in the joy our creations bring to your special moments. Here are some of the wonderful things our customers have shared about their experiences. Thank you for being a part of our sweet journey!
Absolutely delicious! Owner and her husband are top notch. Not only delivered the best pumpkin cheesecake I’ve ever had, but did it with a genuine smile. Outstanding service and top notch cheesecake. Will definitely support this small business for my future get together and meetings!
Truly deliciousness from their kitchen to yours! Whether it’s all for yourself, a family gathering or special treat for someone, this local small business never fails to impress with a variety of flavors to choose from!
Cake It Or Leave It has been one of my favorites and I’m so sad they moved! I’ve seen the beginning and the ups and down and I’m so proud of where this business is now and all that’s in store. Cake It Or Leave It always made me the tastiest cheesecakes and so creative as well! They catered my son’s 1st birthday party and everyone loved the various cheesecake options. You’ll be getting a quality product made with love and a passion for cooking!
Our Sweet Story
Encouraged by James, Darling decided to rebrand and expand her business. Together, they brainstormed and planned a new approach, focusing on baking everything from scratch. They renamed the business to “Cake It or Leave It,” reflecting their commitment to quality and creativity….
Their offerings include cheesecake cookies, sugar cookies, brownies, regular chocolate chip cookies, individual bread, and Guyanese-style pound cake. Each product is crafted with care and passion, reflecting Darling’s dedication to quality and creativity. We use only the finest, freshest ingredients in our desserts. Each dessert is carefully handcrafted with love and attention to detail. Your satisfaction is our priority, offering customized creations and top-notch customer service. Our mission is to bring joy to every occasion with handcrafted, delicious desserts…..
Quick Links
Home
About Us
Menu
Events & Cat.
Blog
Contact Us
FAQ
Contact Information
Address:
197 Oleander road, lake wales fl 33898 United States United States
Phone:
(863) 614-0400
Email:
darling@cakeitorleaveitllc.com
Business Hours:
Monday – Tuesday : CLOSED
Wednesday – Friday : 10AM – 8PM
Saturday : 3PM – 8PM
Sunday : CLOSED
Social Media
Follow us for the
latest updates